You might think: "That's normal. It means those are really the best! The reason that the same companies always make it to the "top" is that those companies, one way or another, pay to be listed there.
Most of the time you run across a so-called "top web hosting companies" list, all of the companies listed as run an affiliate program through Commission Junction (www.cj.com).
No, there's nothing wrong with Commission Junction or with getting paid for referrals. It's a known fact though, that the web hosting companies running their affiliate programs through Commission Junction offer among the highest affiliate commissions in the hosting industry. So, some "clever" guys thought about it: why not create websites with "top web hosting companies" lists and list these companies as "top"?
The really wrong part comes just now though: they don't rank them based on the quality of service (although they claim to), but more on the *size* of the commission or how easy it is to sell the hosting package, and with little to no regard for the service quality or actual reputation of the host. The companies offering the highest commissions and the lowest prices will often get the top spots.
At the time of this writing, I did a research on those companies myself. Out of over 20 companies, only 2 proved to be quality web hosts according to what real people (their customers) said about them. It's also true that there wasn't much to be found about many of the companies. However, what's really worrying is the fact that except for one company (which is very good indeed), the companies that are usually listed in the top 5 are bad or really bad. In fact, there are so many negative reviews about them (real, honest reviews) that they would easily qualify to be listed in any "top